Creamy Shrimp Pie

This beachy treat blends juicy shrimp with melty cheese inside a crisp, golden shell. The mix of tangy chive-onion cream cheese with spicy pepper Jack makes a creamy backdrop that works wonders with the sweet shrimp, giving you something fancy yet totally comforting.

When I was cooking down on Florida's shoreline, I'd whip this pie up for everything from chill family meals to fancy get-togethers. The first time friends tried it at a seaside party, they couldn't believe how little work it took.

Key Ingredients Breakdown

• Shrimp: Go for medium ones that are patted really dry
• Cream Cheese: The chive-onion kind already packs tons of flavor
• Pepper Jack: Gives a nice kick and melts beautifully
• Pie Crust: Pick the deep-dish type to fit everything
• Eggs: They'll turn into a lovely custardy base
• Seasonings: The flavored cream cheese handles most of this

Crafting Your Delicious Pie

Get The Shell Ready:

Bake the crust a bit first so it stays crunchy.

Mix The Base:

Whip that cream cheese until it's super smooth.

Work In The Eggs:

Mix them in one by one so they blend right.

Put In The Good Stuff:

Gently stir in your shrimp and cheeses.

Watch While Baking:

Look for that golden top and firm middle.

Pin it

My beach kitchen teacher always told me, 'Let the seafood be the star.' After making countless pies, I've found this simple advice really matters.

Perfect Pairings

This goes great with a light green salad, some roasted asparagus spears, or a glass of cold white wine. When serving as snacks, cut tiny pieces and top with fresh herbs.

Mix It Up

Switch things around by trying new cheese combos, throwing in some veggies, or adding crab instead. Want more heat? Just use extra pepper Jack or sprinkle in some cayenne pepper.

Keeping It Fresh

Cover and keep in your fridge for up to three days. When you want leftovers, warm single pieces in the oven so the crust stays crispy.

After tweaking this dish for years, I've learned that good prep work and taking your time make all the difference. When you don't rush the steps, you'll end up with a pie that brings a taste of the coast right to your dinner table.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I swap frozen shrimp with fresh?

Of course! Just cook them first, drain well, and cut them small to avoid a runny filling.

→ How do I tell if the pie's ready?

The filling should look firm, with a light golden top. If it seems wobbly, pop it back in for a few.

→ Can this pie be prepped early?

Yep, bake it ahead and reheat when needed. It's best served warm, not too hot.

→ Can this dish be frozen?

Technically, yes, but it's better fresh. Freezing could mess with the creamy consistency.

→ What pairs well with it?

A crisp salad or some steamed greens work really well with this rich pie.