Pin
Enjoy silky rotini swirled with smoky bacon, sweet peas, and two kinds of cheddar all tossed in a zesty homemade ranch. You’ll bite into freshness along with a pop of flavor in every mouthful. It's cool, loaded, and awesome for backyard eats or sunny gatherings. The dressing is light but extra satisfying thanks to the crunchy bacon and rich cheese.
I first threw this together for a party on the lawn. Everyone finished it before anything else—now my buddies always want me to make it again.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Fresh parsley: chopped up for a little brightness Use flat leaf if you can find it
- Sharp cheddar cheese: brings a tangy punch I always cube it myself for best results
- Smoked cheddar cheese: gives a bold smoky twist Grab a block and cut into small chunks
- Frozen peas: sweet and quick-cooking I like the petite ones for tender bites
- Bacon: fry until extra crunchy before adding in Chop into bits
- Black pepper: some heat to balance the creaminess
- Kosher salt: flavors everything evenly without making it harsh
- Garlic powder and onion powder: layer on yummy savory notes Make sure yours are still good and not old
- Dried dill: classic ranch taste and smells amazing when fresh
- Buttermilk: keeps things zingy and smooth Use the liquid kind or mix powdered with water
- Greek yogurt: makes everything tangy and creamy Go for plain, full-fat for best taste
- Mayonnaise: the base for creamy flavor I like it extra thick
- Rotini pasta: all those twists grab onto the good stuff Pick your favorite brand so it stays firm
Simple Step-by-Step
- Chill and Serve
- Let it chill in your fridge for at least half an hour. It’ll taste way better once everything’s nice and cold and blended together.
- Combine Everything
- Stir chilled pasta, thawed peas, bacon bits, both cheddars, and parsley in a big bowl. Pour your ranch dressing over and toss till it’s all coated.
- Cook the Bacon
- Chop strips of bacon into pieces and fry them over medium, letting them go until really crispy. Lay on paper towels and let cool so it stays crunchy.
- Let Pasta Cool and Thaw Peas
- Spread drained rotini out so it cools fast, and toss your peas in a strainer under cold water until they’re thawed and bright green.
- Mix Up the Ranch Dressing
- Whisk mayo, Greek yogurt, buttermilk, dill, garlic powder, onion powder, salt, and pepper together until creamy and smooth. Pop the dressing in the fridge till you’re ready to dump it in.
- Boil Your Pasta
- Boil rotini in salty water following the packet, drain when just firm, don’t overcook. Spread out to cool so it doesn’t stick or get mushy.
Pin
The smoked cheddar totally makes it—no bottled ranch can compare. My niece begged to make it herself after trying just one bite at a family cookout.
How to Store It
This pasta stays fresh in a sealed container in your fridge for three days. Save some bacon to add right before you eat so it stays crispy. Prepping for a party? Stir in cheese and bacon at the end, so nothing gets soggy.
Swaps and Switches
Use penne, bow ties, or orecchiette if you don’t have rotini. Go half mayo, half sour cream for a lighter feel. Turkey bacon or some cooked chicken work great for protein. Mix up the cheese with Colby or pepper jack too.
Perfect Pairings
This creamy salad goes great with grilled chicken, burgers, BBQ, or even veggie platters for a meat-free meal. Double the batch for potlucks and top with extra parsley and plenty of cheddar chunks in a big bowl.
Why This Dish Feels Like Home
Cold pasta salads were huge in American kitchens since the 80s, and ranch is everyone’s go-to for that tangy creamy hit. This one’s got upgrades: some smoky cheese, a handful of fresh herbs, and it just feels special whether you’re feeding a crowd or having a chill night in.
Recipe Questions & Answers
- → Can I substitute another pasta shape?
Definitely! If you don't have rotini, grab penne, bow ties, orecchiette, or whatever small pasta you like. Just cook them firm and chill well before you toss with the dressing.
- → How do I ensure the salad stays creamy?
Let your pasta cool off first. Sticking it in the fridge on a sheet pan keeps it from sucking up the dressing too quickly, so your salad stays creamy and rich.
- → Can I make this dish ahead of time?
Yep! Mix everything a few hours early and stash it in the fridge. It’ll taste super fresh when you’re ready to eat.
- → Is it possible to use only one type of cheese?
For sure. Just toss in smoked cheddar or go easy on the cheese for a lighter bowl. It still tastes great.
- → What can I use instead of bacon?
Want a veggie twist? Add in roasted chickpeas, sautéed mushrooms, or just skip the bacon if you like a different texture.