Cinnamon Sugar Muffins

These soft, golden French Toast Muffins turn a breakfast classic into handy, grab-and-go treats. They pack all the good stuff from traditional French toast – that custardy bread texture, warm cinnamon flavor, and sweet sugar coating – but in a convenient muffin shape that works great for rushed mornings or lazy weekend gatherings. I've whipped these up countless times at home, and my family always gets excited. My little one loves to help with the cinnamon sugar sprinkles, though I've got to keep an eye out because somehow half the sugar mix tends to vanish before it ends up on our muffins!

Must-Have Ingredients Breakdown

* Slightly stale bread: You need bread that's a day old and a bit dry so it can drink up the custard mixture. A hearty French loaf or brioche works wonders here * Heavy cream and whole milk: This combo creates the creamiest, most delicious custard that'll make every bite super soft and tasty * Large eggs: These hold everything together while giving you that authentic French toast flavor we all crave * Real vanilla extract: Adds a wonderful depth that works with the cinnamon. Skip the fake stuff – real vanilla makes all the difference * Cinnamon powder: This warm spice is what makes these muffins so addictive. Try to use freshly opened cinnamon for the strongest flavor

Making Your Breakfast Treats

Prepping Your Bread Slice your day-old bread into small, even 1-inch chunks to make sure they soak evenly. Set them aside while you work on the wet mixture. Mixing The Custard Beat your eggs, milk, cream, sugar, vanilla, and cinnamon together until everything looks smooth. You want a rich, fragrant liquid. Soaking Time Carefully mix bread chunks into your custard, making sure every piece gets coated. Let them sit for 10 minutes, occasionally pushing down lightly. Filling The Cups Scoop your soaked bread into a prepared muffin pan, pressing just enough to fill each cup without squashing the bread too much. Adding The Sweet Touch Pour some melted butter over each muffin and shower them with cinnamon sugar so they all get an even sweet coating. Oven Time Bake until they turn golden brown and set up nicely – look for that sweet spot where the tops get slightly crisp but the middle stays soft and custardy.

Pin it

My grandma always told me the secret to amazing French toast was taking your time with the soaking step. She never used fresh bread, saying bread that's a day old soaks up all that eggy goodness much better. After making these muffins for years now, I can tell you she was absolutely right.

Tasty Companions

Make your breakfast complete with some tasty sides. For special mornings, add some fresh berries and a spoonful of whipped cream. If you want something more filling, try some crispy bacon or breakfast sausage links to balance out the sweetness. A hot cup of coffee or cocoa goes perfectly with these sweet treats.

Customizing Your Creation

Put your own spin on these muffins to match your taste buds. Try mixing in fresh blueberries or small apple chunks before baking for fruity flavor pops. Add a dollop of cream cheese in the middle for a creamy surprise. Want some crunch? Scatter chopped pecans or walnuts on top before they go in the oven. Chocolate chips make them extra special for kids and grown-ups alike.

Staying Fresh

Keep your muffins tasting great with proper storage. They'll stay good in a sealed container on your counter for a couple days, or in the fridge for about five days. When you want one, just warm it up quickly in the microwave or oven to bring back that fresh-baked softness. A quick minute under the broiler will make the cinnamon sugar topping crispy again. I've tweaked this recipe for years and now these muffins give us the best of both worlds – all the yummy flavors we love from French toast but so much easier to make and eat. They've become our go-to family breakfast, especially during holidays when everyone wakes up to that amazing smell of cinnamon and vanilla coming from the kitchen.

Getting The Technique Right

Be gentle when you're putting the soaked bread into your muffin tins. A soft touch keeps the bread texture just right, giving you that perfect mix of custardy softness and crispy golden top. Keep an eye on them while they bake – you want them golden brown but still soft and custardy in the middle.

Changing With The Seasons

Switch things up based on the time of year. Try adding pumpkin spice in autumn, some orange zest during Christmas time, or toss in summer berries when they're fresh. Each season gives you a chance to reinvent these muffins while keeping that comforting, familiar base.

Keeping Them Fresh

Let your muffins cool completely before you store them. If you're freezing some, wrap each one in plastic first, then put them in a freezer bag. This double wrapping stops freezer burn and keeps every muffin tasting fresh until you're ready to eat it. These French Toast Muffins have become my breakfast trademark, blending old-school flavors with new-school convenience. They show how sometimes the tastiest new ideas come from giving classics a twist. Whether they're the star of a fancy brunch or grabbed on the way out the door, they always bring happiness and comfort to everyone who tries them.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I prepare these in advance?

Definitely! Prep the custard and bread the night before, then bake fresh in the morning. Stored muffins last 2-3 days in a sealed container.

→ What bread is good for this?

Bread that’s a day old is best since it holds custard without breaking apart. Try brioche, French bread, or slightly stale white bread.

→ Can I freeze them?

Yep! They freeze well for up to three months. Let them thaw overnight and heat quickly in the oven or microwave when ready to eat.

→ Why are my muffins soggy?

Make sure your bread isn’t too soft and don’t let it soak too long. Preheat the oven fully so they bake properly without being wet.

→ What can I serve alongside?

Top them with powdered sugar or maple syrup, and pair with berries, whipped cream, bacon, or sausage for a balanced morning meal.