Pin it
The sweet vanilla scent mixes with fresh espresso as I stack these single-serving tiramisu cups. I switched to these individual portions after making big trays for years, and found they're not just fancier looking but give everyone their own special bit of this Italian favorite. You can see all the pretty layers through each cup - fluffy mascarpone cream and coffee-dipped ladyfingers, topped with a sprinkle of dark cocoa that makes every bite pure heaven.
I made these for some friends at dinner last week, and my buddy Maria who's from Naples said they reminded her of her grandmother's recipe. That's when I knew I'd nailed the mix of old-school flavor in a new-school package.
Key Ingredients
- Mascarpone Cheese: Try to get authentic Italian stuff and leave it out till it reaches room temp for better mixing
- Heavy Cream: Grab one with more fat content to keep your filling nice and firm
- Authentic Ladyfingers (Savoiardi): The Italian-made ones soak up liquid just right
- Fresh Espresso: Make it right before using for the boldest taste
- Coffee Liqueur: You can skip this, but it really adds something special
- Cocoa Powder: Go for Dutch-processed for that amazing dark color
Crafting Your Tiramisu
- Get the Cream Right:
- Always start with mascarpone that's not cold from the fridge or you'll get chunks. Beat your cream until it just forms soft peaks and watch it closely. Mix the mascarpone with sugar first to avoid any grittiness. Then combine everything using gentle upward strokes. Add vanilla at the end with minimal stirring. Your mixture should feel light but hold its shape - like soft clouds.
- Nail the Coffee Part:
- Make your espresso and cool it down completely. Mix in some coffee liqueur if you want - it really brings out great flavors. Put it in a flat dish that makes dipping easy. Always have extra ladyfingers handy since they sometimes break. Just remember a super quick dip makes them perfect.
- Build It Up:
- Dip each cookie for just one second - no longer! Break them to fit your glasses if needed. Add the cream gently with a spoon or piping bag. Tap your cups a bit to get rid of air bubbles. Keep adding layers and finish with cream on top. Dust some cocoa powder before putting them in the fridge.
- Finish Like a Pro:
- Let them chill at least 2 hours but overnight works even better. Add one last sprinkle of cocoa right when you're ready to serve. Throw on some chocolate shavings if you're feeling fancy. Serve with tiny spoons for the full fancy experience.
Pin it
My first try making these cups was awful - the cookies turned to mush and the cream was all lumpy. But I figured out that gentle folding and super quick dipping were the tricks to getting it just right.
Pin it
Wrapping Up
These little tiramisu cups have become my go-to fancy dessert when friends come over. There's something special about giving each person their own perfect serving of this Italian classic. Whether it's a birthday dinner or just a Friday night at home, remember that great tiramisu comes down to taking your time, buying good ingredients, and never skimping on the cocoa dusting. Enjoy!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make them early?
- Sure, you can prep them a day ahead. They taste even better chilled overnight.
- → Do I need coffee liqueur?
- Nope, it’s optional. For a non-alcoholic twist, stick to strong coffee.
- → What keeps ladyfingers from getting too soft?
- Just dip them quickly in coffee so they soak lightly without falling apart.
- → Can I freeze these little servings?
- Freezing isn’t ideal since it can mess with the mascarpone’s texture.
- → What if I don’t have mascarpone?
- You can swap it out with cream cheese blended with a bit of heavy cream, though it’s not the traditional choice.