Pin
Think about those packaged oatmeal sandwich cookies from when you were a kid. I've whipped up a from-scratch version that'll blow those memories out of the water! My recipe pairs chewy, butter-rich oatmeal cookies with an unbelievably fluffy cream center. What's great? They're crafted with simple, natural ingredients you can actually read - nothing funky added.
What Makes These Top The Store Versions
After one bite of these handcrafted treats, you'll toss those factory-made ones for good. Real butter and quality ingredients totally transform the flavor. I just love seeing folks' surprised expressions when they taste one - it's like they're kids again, but with a much tastier upgrade.
Your Ingredient List
- Old-Fashioned Oats: Don't grab quick oats, they won't work the same.
- Regular Flour: Nothing fancy needed here.
- Baking Soda: This gives your cookies that nice rise.
- Salt: Leave it out if your butter already has salt.
- Cozy Spices: Ginger, nutmeg and cinnamon create that familiar warmth.
- Unsalted Butter: This lets you control the saltiness.
- Three Sugars: Powdered, brown and white each do something special.
- Molasses: Your ticket to perfectly chewy cookies.
- Eggs: A whole one plus just the yolk for extra richness.
- Vanilla: Real extract makes all the difference.
- Cream Cheese: This turns your filling into something heavenly.
Pin
Simple Baking Steps
- Prep Time
- Get your oven going at 350°F and put parchment on your cookie sheets.
- Combine Dry Ingredients
- Stir together your oats, flour, baking soda, spices and salt.
- Butter Base
- Whip the butter with all sugars until light and airy, then stir in the molasses.
- Liquid Mix-ins
- Drop in eggs and vanilla, mixing till smooth.
- Complete The Dough
- Slowly add your dry mix - be careful not to stir too much!
- Form And Cook
- Drop spoonfuls, press down slightly and bake about 9 minutes until edges set.
- Whip Up Filling
- Beat together cream cheese, butter, powdered sugar and vanilla until super fluffy.
- Assembly Time
- After cookies cool completely, spread filling on one and top with another.
Storage Tips
You can leave plain cookies out at room temp for a couple days. Ones with filling should go in the fridge in a sealed container. Though in my house, they usually disappear way too fast to worry about storing them!
Plan Ahead Options
You can freeze these babies with or without filling for up to three months. The cookie dough balls can go in the freezer too, so you can bake them fresh when you want a treat. Just don't forget to let them thaw in your fridge overnight first.
Recipe Questions & Answers
- → Why skip quick oats?
Rolled oats bring texture and chew, which quick oats just lack.
- → What’s the deal with room temp ingredients?
When butter, eggs, and cream cheese aren’t cold, they mix smoother for a better end result.
- → Can these be prepped in advance?
Yep! Keep them in the fridge for up to 5 days. Let them sit at room temp before enjoying.
- → Why stick to one baking sheet at once?
One sheet at a time means they bake evenly and get just the right texture.
- → Can I freeze them?
Yes, freeze the unfilled cookies for up to 3 months. Assemble them fresh after thawing to keep the best texture.