Pin it
A velvety green minty drink that outdoes the iconic fast-food favorite, whipped up in just moments with only four simple items. Great for killing those seasonal shake cravings whenever they hit.
I found this method after trying various flavorings - turns out peppermint extract, not regular mint, gives you that genuine flavor you're after.
Key Components:
- Premium vanilla ice cream
- Whole milk: Gives the perfect consistency
- Peppermint extract: For that true taste
- Green food coloring: Not required but adds fun
Pin it
Step-by-Step Guide:
- Get Your Glass Ready
- Line the edge with honey
- Roll in green sprinkles
- Keep cold while mixing drink
- Put aside
- Mix Your Drink
- Scoop ice cream into blender
- Add your milk
- Use 1/4 tsp extract first
- Put in some green drops
- Get The Right Thickness
- Mix until it's smooth
- Check how thick it is
- Pour more milk if too thick
- Taste and add more mint if needed
- Drink Right Away
- Fill your glass
- Add whipped cream on top
- Drop a cherry on if you want
- Use a big straw
The biggest breakthrough was switching to peppermint extract instead of mint extract - this totally gets rid of that weird toothpaste flavor.
Different Ways To Make It:
Switch to chocolate ice cream or drizzle in some chocolate sauce for a mint chocolate twist.
Keeping It Fresh:
Drink it right away. It doesn't keep well in the freezer.
Non-Dairy Options:
Swap in plant-based ice cream and milk and you'll still get amazing results.
Pin it
Pro Tricks:
- Chill your glass first
- Go for top-notch ice cream
- Pulse instead of continuous blending
- Go easy on the extract at first
I tried tons of different ways to make this at home, and nailing both the extract type and how you blend it creates a perfect match to the famous version.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How much peppermint flavoring?
- Begin with 1/4 teaspoon, adjust as needed. It’s potent.
- → What kind of coloring works?
- Liquid dye works well, but gel is fine. Just use less if needed.
- → Dairy-free options available?
- Use almond milk with pudding mix for a creamy alternative.
- → How thick should it feel?
- Tweak milk quantity till it's how you like it.
- → Can I prep ahead of time?
- Best enjoyed fresh. It may separate if stored.