Pin
At my place, nothing beats a chicken pot pie for cozy vibes. You get this golden, flaky crust holding in a hearty, creamy mix of chicken and veggies. It’s the ultimate comfort food when you’re craving warmth—especially when the weather's chilly or you’re missing old-school homemade meals.
I first made this pot pie for a low-key Sunday night after a rough week. After that, everyone started asking for it whenever comfort food was in order. Plates are always wiped clean and people line up for seconds.
Inviting Ingredients
- All-purpose flour: thickens everything up, just give it a sift for a lump-free gravy
- Heavy cream: splashes in a rich, creamy feel—choose fresh if you can
- Yellow onion: sweetens up the filling; go for a firm one, no squishy spots
- Frozen peas: add a pop of color and natural sweetness, throw 'em in frozen
- Cooked shredded chicken: rotisserie chicken saves you loads of time and gives deep, savory taste
- Homemade pie crust: buttery homemade wins for flaky layers or go store-bought if you’re short on time
- Carrots: slices of color and sweetness—cut them thin for even cooking
- Chicken stock: makes a flavorful base, try low-sodium so you don’t over-salt
- Egg: beat an egg to brush the top, that’s how you get shiny, browned crust
- Parsley: chop and sprinkle at the end for a fresh green boost
- Garlic: makes it extra savory and aromatic, fresh cloves work best
- Fine sea salt: add as you go, tasting to get it just right
- White or brown mushrooms: toss them in for umami—avoid any that look shriveled
- Black pepper: a dash brings spice and deeper flavor
- Unsalted butter: use a new stick for that extra silky, rich base
Straightforward Instructions
- Let it Cool and Dish Up:
- Set the pie out for about fifteen minutes after baking. This way the filling firms up, and your slices will come out nice and neat.
- Bake It Off:
- Crank the oven to 425°F. Brush the top with egg for gloss—extra salt and pepper if you want. Bake until it’s bubbling and golden, about thirty to thirty-five minutes. Wrap the crust edges with foil if they start to brown too fast.
- Top and Bottom Crusts:
- Roll out one piece of dough to fit your pan and press it in. Pile in the chicken mix. Lay the second dough on top, pinch the edges, and cut a few vents so steam can sneak out.
- Mix Up the Filling:
- Take the skillet off the heat. Stir in chicken, parsley, and peas so you’ve got greens and oranges flecked all over. Just give it a good mix.
- Simmer Gravy:
- Pour in your stock little by little, stirring so it doesn’t clump. Mix in cream and let it bubble for a minute until thick. Toss in some salt and pepper at this point, taste and adjust.
- Thicken with Flour:
- Dust flour over the veggies and stir for two minutes so you cook away the raw taste and help it thicken up later.
- Sauté the Veggies:
- Start by softening onion and carrot in butter over medium for eight minutes. Add garlic and mushrooms; cook another five until they’re soft and it smells awesome.
Pin
Honestly, I’m obsessed with how buttery the crust gets next to that creamy inside. Once my partner just couldn’t wait and burnt their tongue trying to sneak a slice straight from the oven—the smell is just that tempting.
Storing leftovers
Stick the pie in the fridge covered and it’ll hold up for three or four days. For longer, freeze it well wrapped for up to three months. Warm up slices in the oven so the crust goes back to crisp—skip the microwave for best results.
Easy swaps
Turkey works great if you’ve got some left after a holiday. Try green beans, corn, or sweet potatoes for a veggie spin. Going dairy-free? Swap butter for olive oil and use oat milk instead of cream for the sauce.
How to serve it up
Serve up big pieces with a fresh green salad or some simply steamed beans. Cranberry sauce on the side brings on those holiday feels. If you’re in the mood for something bolder, dash on hot sauce or add extra herbs before you bake it.
Time-honored background
Chicken pot pies go back to America’s colonial days, but folks in Europe have baked meaty pies even longer. The creamy filling under a pastry shell made them both budget-friendly and super tasty. Families often packed them with whatever veggies and leftovers they had, so every household had their own take.
Recipe Questions & Answers
- → How can I keep the bottom crust from turning soggy?
Start with cold dough, keep the baking sheet hot, and make sure your filling isn’t super runny before you fill the pie.
- → Can I change up the veggies?
For sure! Toss in corn, green beans, or spuds if you want to swap out the carrots or mushrooms.
- → What chicken should I use?
Rotisserie chicken works great, or just poach some chicken breast for a quick, tasty fix.
- → What’s the best way to save leftovers?
Let it cool down, toss on some plastic wrap, and store it in the fridge for up to four days. Reheat in your oven so the crust stays crunchy.
- → Can I freeze my pot pie?
You bet—freeze the unbaked pie or leftover pieces. When you’re ready, make sure it’s heated through and steamy before serving.