Pin
Creamy Mississippi Mud Potatoes steal the show as a filling, craveable favorite at holiday feasts or family get-togethers. It’s wild how basic ingredients turn into a gooey, cheesy dish with crisp bacon in every scoop—super comforting! There’s just something about dunking your spoon into that bubbling hot pan and tasting that can’t-stop combo every time.
First time I pulled this out for a Sunday meal, the pan was empty before anyone got seconds. Now my family begs for it at every event!
Irresistible Ingredients
- Onion: chopped up to bring mellow sweetness and round things out. Grab a heavy yellow or sweet one.
- Bacon: cooked and crumbled so you get smoky, crunchy pieces in every bite. Thick cut is best if you want chunkier texture.
- Cheddar cheese: grate it fresh if you can for bold flavor and smooth meltiness. Go for sharp for the most zing.
- Mayonnaise: brings all the creaminess and ties it together. Rich, full-fat mayo makes the whole thing more luscious.
- Russet potatoes: peel and chop so they're soft inside but not mushy outside. Pick potatoes that look solid and don't have green bits.
- Garlic: minced up to make the dish smell and taste warmer. Fresh garlic’s my favorite for max flavor.
Easy Step-by-Step Guide
- Dish It Up Hot:
- When it’s golden and bubbling, spoon out generous helpings straight from the pan. Crispy top and creamy inside is what makes it addictive.
- Bake Till Just Right:
- Let it go uncovered in the center of your oven about one and a half hours. Don’t forget to stir halfway so everything cooks even and the top gets that golden look.
- Stir in Mayo:
- Scoop mayonnaise in and gently fold so every chunk gets coated. This is how you nail that crave-worthy creamy texture.
- Mix Everything Together:
- Toss potatoes, cheddar, bacon, onion, and garlic right into your prepped baking dish. Mix it up so it’s all evenly spread out.
- Warm Up the Oven and Pan:
- Bump your oven to 325°F. Use some butter or spray to grease a 9x13 inch pan, so you don’t lose any of that cheesy crust to sticking.
Pin
Bacon in this always makes me think of my grandpa, who swore no casserole was finished without it. Sharing this warm pan brings me right back to those big, loud family dinners and silly stories around the table.
Keep It Fresh
Let leftovers cool first, then wrap up tight or pop into a sealed container. Chill in the fridge for up to three days. If you want to freeze it, make single-servings—let them thaw overnight before reheating and digging in.
Swaps and Variations
If mayo’s not your thing, switch to Greek yogurt for a tangy twist or use part sour cream and less mayo. Want heat? Dice up some jalapenos or sprinkle smoked paprika. If you’re skipping meat, sautéed mushrooms work in place of bacon.
Ideas for Serving
This cheesy classic fits right beside steak, roast chicken, or becomes the star at a brunch get-together. Try it with a simple salad or roasted veggies if you want a more balanced plate.
Where It Comes From
This golden-brown side has deep roots in Southern communities, adapting a bit in every kitchen. Some folks toss in pimentos or extra green onions while others go heavy on bacon. It’s a comforting go-to because the ingredients are simple, cheap, and always on hand in country homes.
Recipe Questions & Answers
- → Which potatoes should I use for this?
Try Russet or Yukon Gold—they keep their shape and end up lush and creamy, so they work great here.
- → Is it okay to make this earlier?
You can totally mix everything, pop it in the fridge overnight, and just bake whenever you're ready. The texture stays awesome this way.
- → Any tips for making it less heavy?
Try swapping in some plain Greek yogurt or sour cream instead of mayo. You can also pick lighter cheese blends to take the richness down a notch.
- → What extra toppings taste good?
Add sliced green onion, chopped jalapeño, or even a little smoked paprika on top for a boost of flavor and color.
- → Can people eating gluten-free enjoy this?
Absolutely—all the main stuff here is already gluten-free. Just double check that any toppings or mix-ins you use don't sneak in gluten.