Pin
Bite into chicken packed with rich garlic mushrooms and gooey cheese that just melts. It’s for those nights you want something special but easy. You can pour that creamy Parmesan sauce over—but honestly, this meal tastes awesome even without it.
This all started when I had way too many mushrooms and nowhere to put them. Suddenly this dish was all I wanted. My buddies always clear their plates and ask me how I make it.
Effortless Ingredients
- Toothpicks: Keep those handy to hold your chicken shut while it cooks—sturdy wood ones are best
- Onion powder and dried parsley: Toss in background flavor and light herby taste
- Salt and pepper: Helps balance everything—taste and tweak as you go
- Half and half or milk plus cream: It’s what makes that sauce silky—use the freshest stuff possible
- Garlic: The star for classic boldness—grab cloves that feel solid and fresh
- Brown mushrooms: Their strong earthy kick makes the dish. Slice ’em thick so they stay juicy
- Moist mozzarella cheese: Think stretchy, cheesy pulls—shred a block yourself for best melt
- Fresh parsley: For sprinkling at the end—colorful and bright
- Chicken breasts: Look for ones that are plump and even, so stuffing’s a breeze
- Dijon mustard: Brings a little sharp zip to the sauce—choose smooth and good quality
- Butter: Loads the filling with flavor and keeps chicken tasting awesome—go unsalted
- Olive oil: Used for the sauce if you want it—get extra virgin for the best flavor
- Parmesan cheese: Gives a salty, punchy finish—grate yours right before you start
Simple How-To Steps
- Serve It Up:
- After yanking out those toothpicks, put the chicken back in the pan and ladle that creamy sauce on top. Take a deep breath and dig in.
- Finishing in the Oven:
- Cover the pan and slide it into a hot oven, around four hundred degrees Fahrenheit, letting the chicken hit one sixty-five inside. Should take about twenty minutes. Hang out while it cooks and get your sauce going.
- Browning Time:
- Keep the same skillet on medium-high. Get any leftover garlic butter sizzling, then lay in your stuffed chicken, pretty side down. Let it crust up to a deep golden shade before flipping to brown the other side.
- Fill and Close It:
- Take each chicken pocket, put in a couple slices of mozzarella, shovel in those garlicky mushrooms, and dust with Parmesan. Pinch it closed and lock shut with a few toothpicks on the diagonal, so nothing escapes.
- Get Chicken Ready:
- Pat chicken dry—this makes the flavor stick. Stir together your parsley, onion powder, salt, and pepper, then rub all over. Cut a big pocket in the thickest side. Don’t slice through, just go deep enough for filling.
- Work The Mushrooms:
- Toss butter in a big oven-friendly pan over medium. Add garlic, let it get fragrant for a minute. Mushrooms, salt, pepper, parsley next. Stir till they shrink and everything goes glossy and smells great. Cool it down so you can stuff without burns.
- Creamy Sauce, If You’re Feeling Fancy:
- Drop olive oil into your skillet and turn the heat real low. Stir in minced garlic till it wakes up your nose, then blend in Dijon. Pour in milk or half and half. Simmer and stir while it thickens. Mix in your leftover mushrooms and a heap of Parmesan. Once melted, toss in parsley. Taste, adjust, and if you want it thicker, add a little cornstarch mixed with water. Stir and you’re golden.
Pin
The mushroom filling is always the best part—I usually steal a little while I’m putting it together. Kids love the stringy cheese too—they poke at it and love helping when this dish is on the stove.
Leftovers and Storage
Wrap leftovers tight and put ’em in the fridge, good for three days. Warm up in the oven with a splash of broth or water to stay juicy. If you freeze fully cooked chicken, use it within two months. The cheese inside might get a bit different but it’s still tasty.
Options for Swapping
No mozzarella? Provolone or fontina work fine too. Trade out brown mushrooms for cremini or plain white if needed. Don’t have half and half? Use a cup each of cream and whole milk. Always pick fresh herbs when you can for big flavor.
Ideas for Serving
Put it with steamed rice, buttery mashed potatoes, roast veggies, or crisp salad. Feeling lighter? Zucchini noodles or cauliflower rice are nice for carrying that sauce but keeping it dialed down on carbs.
Backstory and Inspiration
This meal takes flavors inspired by Italy—cheese, mushrooms, garlic, butter, and fresh herby stuff—but throws them together in a relaxed, North American home cook style. It’s the sort of thing you’d make in the middle of the week and feel just a bit fancy.
Recipe Questions & Answers
- → How do I keep the filling inside the chicken?
Close up the stuffed chicken with a few toothpicks, and just make sure you don't cut the pocket too big. A good sear also helps keep everything tucked in.
- → Can I make this dish without the cream sauce?
For sure, the chicken still turns out juicy and tasty on its own. The sauce is just there to up the richness.
- → What cheeses work best for stuffing?
Mozzarella (the kind that's not super wet) gets all stretchy and gooey, while Parmesan adds a punch of salty flavor. Both melt down great when baking.
- → Which mushrooms should I use?
Earthy cremini or baby bellas are awesome here, but regular white mushrooms will do the trick too.
- → How do I serve this for a lower-carb meal?
Pair it with something like zoodles, riced cauliflower, or a bright, snappy salad to keep things light on carbs.
- → Is it possible to prepare ahead of time?
Yep! Go ahead and stuff your chicken earlier in the day, chill it, and just cook when you're close to eating for the freshest results.